Search
When printing, please print in LANDSCAPE mode.
AnthonyMueller.com Wine Review Database
| Bottle Image | Vintage | Producer Name | Bottle Name | Country / Region / Appellation | Wine Color | Wine Style | Price | Review | Score | Drink Dates |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2009 | Château Pontet-Canet | France, Bordeaux, Pauillac | Red | Table | $200.00 | The 2009 Pontet-Canet remains fresh and classic, showcasing elegance with mineral-driven notes and a firm tannic structure. Its fresh characteristics are complemented by a medium body, contributing to its impressive aging potential. This wine is distinctly mineral-driven and offers a long, complex finish that is both lengthy and elegant—truly a remarkable example of Bordeaux. It stands out as a masterclass in winemaking and is clearly exceeding expectations for its status as a fifth-growth Bordeaux. | 98 | 2018 – 2045 | ||
| 2016 | PYM-RAE Tesseron Estate | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Mount Veeder | Red | Table | $390.00 | Made from a blend of 76% Cabernet Sauvignon, 17% Merlot and 7% Cabernet Franc, the 2016 PYM-RAE red wine is incredibly fresh and tight, featuring firm tannins. It presents a deep magenta color, exuding both freshness and complexity with notes of crème de cassis, complemented by fine mineral tension and leafy undertones of tea leaf. Full-bodied yet still tight, the wine showcases a mineral-driven profile and will require additional time to mature. It promises to be an age-worthy powerhouse. This fantastic inaugural vintage marks a monumental success as the beginning of the Tesseron legacy in Napa. Bravo! | 98 | 2026 – 2050 | ||
| 2017 | PYM-RAE Tesseron Estate | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Mount Veeder | Red | Table | $390.00 | The 2017 PYM-RAE is 80% Cabernet Sauvignon and 20% Merlot, creating a bold and juicy wine featuring delicate notes of purple flowers in the glass. It boasts a classic Napa Cabernet nose, characterized by a harmonious balance of fruit and oak, offering a freshness that’s enjoyable even in its youth. With a medium to full body, this wine has gripping tannins, making it an excellent pairing for roasted meats and wild game. | 96 | 2024 – 2045 | ||
| 2018 | PYM-RAE Tesseron Estate | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Mount Veeder | Red | Table | $390.00 | Every so often, a truly remarkable wine comes along that will remain in your memory for a lifetime. The 2018 PYM-RAE is such a wine. It is a blend of 65% Cabernet Sauvignon, 30% Merlot, and 5% Cabernet Franc. This beautiful wine–flirting with triple digits–offers a classic freshness with a captivating combination of red and black fruits that reflects its unique terroir on top of Mount Veeder. Medium to full-bodied, it exudes elegance and grace with sophistication and power, showcasing notes of blackberry, black cherry, and cassis, all complemented by well-integrated oak. The finish is long and persistent and it just doesn’t quit! It’s an utterly impressive wine that has me smitten. If you can find it, then the time, effort, and money spent to buy an entire case will be well worth it! Bravo! | 99 | 2026 – 2060 | ||
| 2019 | PYM-RAE Tesseron Estate | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Mount Veeder | Red | Table | $390.00 | Composed of 80% Cabernet Sauvignon, 15% Merlot, and 5% Cabernet Franc, the 2019 is big and juicy, showcasing an abundance of attractive fruit and remarkable freshness. Medium to full-bodied, it features a velvety texture and a complex profile with hints of blue, black, and dark red fruits. The wine delivers elegance and grace, paired with firm tannins and a spicy, juicy finish. Well done! | 98+ | 2025 – 2055 | ||
| 2020 | PYM-RAE Tesseron Estate | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Mount Veeder | Red | Table | $390.00 | Mostly Cabernet Sauvignon, with 25% Merlot and 15% Cabernet Franc, the 2020 PYM-RAE is fresh and delightfully herbal, featuring complex layers of violets and basil that showcase style, sense of place, and regionality. With a world-class approach, the wine evolves into a full-bodied expression that somersaults to a long, lingering finish. It is a complex and refreshing choice that will satisfy Cabernet lovers around the globe. The balance of fruit, herbs, and oak, complemented by floral notes, is truly beautiful. Keep an eye on this producer, and good luck finding any of their exquisite wines! | 97 | 2027 – 2060 | ||
| 2014 | Siefert Family Vineyards | Cabernet Sauvignon | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $200.00 | Still floral, fragrant, and lively, the nose showcases fruit-forward energy and is still in fighting shape, possessing remarkable staying power. The 2014 is just now hitting its stride and will continue to offer pleasure with elegance, grace, power, and precision. A pristine example of fine Napa Cabernet Sauvignon, the wine glides to a long finish, presenting slightly spicy and oaky elements with hints of turned earth and developing nuttiness on the aftertaste. This wine will age gracefully for another 8 – 10 years. | 94+ | 2017 – 2034 | |
| 2015 | Siefert Family Vineyards | Cabernet Sauvignon | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $200.00 | This is the first vintage fermented in stainless steel and opens with a fresh, robust nose, bursting with delightful layers of fruit. The 2015 is pure elegance as it meets lush, ripe blackberries, blueberries, spiced plums, and cherries, while French oak contributes complexity, enhancing the medium to full-bodied structure. Hints of Kirsch and Chambord lead to a long, elegant finish that delivers hedonistic pleasure that has me daydreaming of a flame-kissed ribeye. | 95 | 2018 – 2036 | |
| 2016 | Siefert Family Vineyards | Cabernet Sauvignon | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $200.00 | Subtle and subdued on the nose, the 2016 Cabernet is likely in its “cocoon” phase; however, it opens beautifully on the palate with plenty of spice and a plush texture. Medium to full-bodied and with firm tannins, it is destined to shine with food and will benefit from additional time in the bottle. It’s gorgeous now but has excellent aging potential and will continue to improve in the bottle over the next decade-plus. Your patience will be rewarded with another year or two in the bottle. | 94 | 2019 – 2036 | |
| 2017 | Siefert Family Vineyards | Cabernet Sauvignon | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $200.00 | Instantly brilliant, the 2017 Cabernet Sauvignon is firing on all cylinders, exhibiting freshness, finesse, and precision. Bursting with dark red, black, and hints of blue fruit, the nose strikes a perfect balance between oak and supporting fruit structure. Serious Napa Cabernet aficionados and collectors will appreciate its elegance and power, only made more complex by its long and spicy finish. It’s incredibly food-friendly and will benefit from decanting for 30 minutes before drinking. | 96 | 2022 – 2040 | |
| 2018 | Siefert Family Vineyards | Cabernet Sauvignon | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $200.00 | Still showing sticky tannins, this fresh and lush Cabernet is packed with complexity and abundant life. Blackberry, dark cherry, and spiced plums dominate its profile as it presents a classic Napa Cabernet that will reward those who are patient enough to give this wine time to develop and fill its shoes. The 2018 Cabernet Sauvignon stands out as the best of the lineup, and I am not letting a single drop go to waste! It’s a true masterstroke and is as serious and as collectible as they come. Bravo! | 97 | 2022 – 2040 | |
| 2019 | Siefert Family Vineyards | Cabernet Sauvignon | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $200.00 | Lush, fresh, and instantly approachable, the 2019 Cabernet Sauvignon is generous and offers gobs of inky purple flowers and juicy plum essences on the nose. Its floral and perfumed character makes it go down almost too easily, ensuring pleasure for those who prefer their wine on the younger side. There is no need to wait if you don’t have to because this beauty is ready to rock! | 95 | 2023 – 2034 | |
| 2020 | Siefert Family Vineyards | Cabernet Sauvignon | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $200.00 | Fleshy and generous, the nose is black-fruited with hints of roasted coffee beans and features a tight mid-palate that will allow it to pair effortlessly with a wide range of food and cuisines. With its tannic finish, the 2020 Cabernet Sauvignon will be best enjoyed with steaks, chops or wild game. Decanting is recommended. | 92 | 2024 – 2032 | |
| 2021 | Siefert Family Vineyards | Cabernet Sauvignon | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $200.00 | Fleshy, fresh, and floral, this wine carries a kiss of leafiness, expressing a sincere and pure characteristic, as it offers a glimpse into the heart of the Cabernet Sauvignon DNA. Elegant and complex with mineral tension, it reflects the freshness of the 2021 vintage. It’s a classic wine that will benefit from patience and reward those who wait. Give this one some additional time in the bottle. | 94 | 2026 – 2038 | |
| 2022 | Siefert Family Vineyards | Cabernet Sauvignon | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $200.00 | Spicy and fresh, this lush wine features notes of roasted coffee beans, espresso, and hints of ground white peppercorn. Its dark red and black-fruited core is sticky and structured, requiring time to fully express itself. Aged in heavy-toast barrels for the first time, the 2022 Cabernet Sauvignon ends with a long, spice-driven finish that will pair beautifully with the larger, thick cuts of grilled red meats. | 93+ | 2027 – 2035 | |
| 2022 | Bellamy Vineyards | Estate Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon | USA, California, Central Valley, Sacramento County | Red | Table | $45.00 | This Estate Cabernet from Wilton, California, begins with a deep magenta core, immediately offering up an enticing nose filled with blackberry, dark cherry compote, and hints of chocolate-covered blueberries. Earthy notes of turned soil and a subtle essence of smoked cherries add layers of complexity. The palate is both firm and fresh, embodying the warmth of the 2022 vintage with rich flavors of crème de cassis and a soft smokiness that lingers on the finish. This bold yet elegant Cabernet promises a rewarding journey through 2032. | 90 | 2025 – 2032 | |
| 2022 | Bellamy Vineyards | Napa Oakville Cabernet Sauvignon | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Oakville | Red | Table | $150.00 | This 2022 Oakville Cabernet Sauvignon from Napa Valley exhibits an almost opaque core with a deep magenta rim. The nose is layered with oak spices, cedar, baked earth, and graphite, unfolding into an array of dark red and black fruits. Notes of dark cherry, cassis, smoked plum, blackberry reduction, and a touch of dried leaves add to its complexity. The mid-palate shows a generous frame with silky tannins, promising graceful aging for over a decade. A perfect companion for fire-roasted red meats, game, or a hearty barbecue. | 92+ | 2025 – 2035 | |
| 2023 | Bellamy Vineyards | Mariposita Rosé | USA, California | Rosé | Table | $26.00 | The 2023 Mariposita Rosé presents a beautiful pale salmon pink hue. Its elegant floral nose blooms with honeysuckle, jasmine, apricot, quince, marmalade, and hints of candied citrus. The palate is fresh, zesty, and delightfully nimble, versatile enough to enjoy on its own or pair with a wide variety of foods. With a light body and 12% alcohol, the mid-palate brings a satisfying weight and freshness, leading to a succulent finish that invites another sip. This Moscato-based rosé shines with elegance and grace. | 90 | 2025 – 2027 | |
| 2022 | Du Coeur Wines | Cuvée Layla Cabernet Sauvignon | USA, Washington, Columbia Valley, Waluke Slope | Red | Table | $65.00 | The Cuvée Layla, named after the owner’s daughter, presents a deep magenta core. Its aroma is rich with dusty red and black fruit notes, complemented by hints of dusty plum and black cherry skin. As the wine opens, it reveals subtle undertones of bitter dark chocolate and dried violets. This medium to full-bodied wine has a balanced and fresh palate, transitioning from dark red and black fruit flavors to a delightful mineral tension. It features additional notes of baked earth and petrichor, along with a touch of herbal essence and dried flowers. The Cabernet concludes with a lingering, slightly tannic finish, making it a food-friendly option for years to come. Decanting is recommended. | 90 | 2025 – 2032 | |
| 2022 | Du Coeur Wines | Syrah Walla Walla Valley | USA, Oregon, Northern Oregon, Walla Walla Valley, The Rocks District of Milton-Freewater | Red | Table | $60.00 | Instantly recognizable as Walla Walla Valley Syrah, this Syrah, coming from the Stoney Vine Vineyard, will please and excite wine lovers and serious collectors of the region. From the moment you take a sniff, the characteristic aromas of Walla Walla Valley Syrah waft from the glass. The nose presents classic umami notes combined with hints of turned earth, leather, and caramelized brown butter, further complemented by typical Syrah characteristics of black peppercorn and cured meats. On the palate, the wine is velvety and seductive, exuding elegance and finesse, with beautiful floral notes emerging across the mid-palate. As the wine evolves, it gradually reveals a long, lingering finish that is immensely pleasurable. The entire experience is rewarding and invites you to return for more. I dare you to have just one glass! | 94 | 2025 – 2035 | |
| 2022 | Du Coeur Wines | Pinot Noir Domaine Danielle Laurent Vineyard | USA, Oregon, Willamette Valley, Yamhill-Carlton | Red | Table | $55.00 | The 2022 Pinot Noir Domaine Danielle Laurent Vineyard features delicate floral aromas complemented by crunchy red fruit aromas of wild strawberries, red cherries, and hints of cranberry, with a touch of red tea and soft spices, including a whisper of cinnamon and fresh tea leaves. On the palate, the Pinot has succulent acidity and offers a balanced mid-palate supported by silky tannins, making it a food-friendly option for years to come. It concludes with a lingering, mineral-driven finish and vibrant, crunchy red fruit notes. This wine will effortlessly pair well with duck. Nicely done! | 91 | 2025 – 2033 | |
| 2022 | Du Coeur Wines | Pinot Noir Shea Vineyard | USA, Oregon, Willamette Valley, Yamhill-Carlton | Red | Table | $55.00 | Getting a bit more serious, the 2022 Pinot Noir from Shea Vineyard opens with dark red fruit aromas of black cherry skin, along with perfumed notes of potpourri, red plum, and hints of spiced red florals and rose hip, accompanied by a delightful kiss of wild brush. The palate is firm and still tight, showcasing good balance in its more generous and broad expression as it glides across the mid-palate. The slightly drying tannins melt away on the long, lingering finish, which offers hints of jelly-filled cherry candies and tree bark. An additional chill will enhance the wine, and decanting it 30 minutes beforehand is recommended. | 92 | 2026 – 2034 | |
| 2022 | Du Coeur Wines | Pinot Noir Prince Hill Vineyard | USA, Oregon, Willamette Valley, Dundee Hills | Red | Table | $60.00 | The darkest and most savory of the Pinot Noir selections from Du Coeur this year, the 2022 Pinot Noir Prince Hill Vineyard features dark-red fruit alongside persistent notes of turned earth, forest floor, moss, fern, dried tea leaf before notes of dried pomegranate, and strawberry skin set in. On the palate, it is dry, medium to full-bodied, and fresh, with a clean, mineral-driven character. Tertiary notes of wild porcini and wild strawberries emerge before leading to a complex and refreshing finish that remains mineral-driven. This beautifully Pinot will perform exceptionally well at the dinner table. | 92+ | 2025 – 2034 | |
| 2022 | The Donum Estate | Carneros Estate Chardonnay | USA, California, North Coast, Sonoma County, Los Carneros | White | Table | $75.00 | Pale straw in the glass, the 2022 Chardonnay starts a bit shy aromatically, slowly revealing lemon rind and almond skin. On the palate, it’s medium-bodied with subtle richness—marzipan and white melon come forward, supported by a gentle phenolic grip and clean mineral tension. A soft, spiced finish brings in hints of Asian pear, revealing its subdued elegance | 90 | 2025-2031 | |
| 2024 | The Donum Estate | Rosé of Pinot Noir | USA, California, North Coast, Sonoma County, Los Carneros | Rosé | Table | $50.00 | Pale salmon in color and full of charm, this Rosé walks a fine line between fruit and earth. Aromas of strawberry, cherry skin, and Meyer lemon are layered with an intriguing touch of turned earth. There’s a slight prickle on the palate from residual CO₂, so a splash decant and extra chill are recommended. Light to medium-bodied and delightfully fresh. | 90 | 2025-2028 | |
| 2022 | The Donum Estate | Carneros Estate Pinot Noir | USA, California, North Coast, Sonoma County, Los Carneros | Red | Table | $95.00 | This Carneros Pinot leans darker and brooding, with notes of cherry skin, plum compote, lavender, and bitter black tea. There’s a firm tannic grip and a tightly wound finish that begs for food—and perhaps another year or two in the bottle. Enjoy it from 2026 to 2032 with a hearty pairing. At present, it feels unresolved. | 90 | 2026-2032 | |
| 2023 | Pacific Veil | Pinot Noir | USA, California, Central Coast | Red | Table | $20.00 | Bright, juicy, and effortlessly charming, the 2023 Pacific Veil Pinot Noir opens with an inviting nose of cherry cola, black raspberry, and spiced plum. Medium-bodied and approachable, it’s built for the table—showing a soft phenolic grip and lingering tannins that keep things interesting through the finish. It over-delivers for the price and is ready to drink now through 2030. A versatile, easygoing Pinot that punches above its weight class. | 90 | 2025-2030 | |
| NV | Bolle Drinks | Blanc de Blancs | Spain, Castilla La Mancha, La Mancha | White | Sparkling | $30.00 | Clean, refreshing, complex, zesty and citrus driven on the nose with hints of petrol, lemon zest, white peach and muskmelon. Lighter-bodied and refreshing, the palate is clean and crisp, offering notes of yellow apple and citrus blossom before revealing a delightful frothy mousse. While for me, many nonalcoholic wines fall short and thin, this is hands down the best non-alcoholic wine I’ve ever experienced. I want some more! | 91 | 2025-2027 | |
| NV | Bolle Drinks | Rosé | Spain, Castilla La Mancha, La Mancha | Rosé | Sparkling | $30.00 | An impressive non-alcoholic option, the Bolle Rosé is bright and lively with notes of strawberry lemonade and cherry skin. Zippy acidity electrifies the palate, making this feel as precise and balanced as its Blanc de Blanc sibling. The finish is fresh, succulent, and totally satisfying—an excellent option for any occasion. | 90 | 2025-2027 | |
| 2021 | Seven Apart | Expedition | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $185.00 | Dusty red fruit and fresh blackberry combine to create a complex, structured, and expressive wine. The 2021 Expedition is medium to full-bodied and firm, with rich and round flavors that grip the palate. The wine showcases dark cherry notes along with bittersweet dark chocolate. The finish is long, smooth and food-friendly as it lingers with focus. Hints of graphite add to its elegance, making it an impressive offering. | 93 | 2024-2038 | |
| 2021 | Seven Apart | Shale | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Atlas Peak | Red | Table | $295.00 | Still tight and fresh, the 2021 Shale Cabernet showcases a mineral-driven nose before black cherry and dusty plum express from the glass. It has dark red fruit flavors and is full-bodied. The mouthfeel compresses to reveal layers of complexity of bitter dark chocolate and roasted espresso beans. The wine has a delightful, well-integrated finish that balances between dark fruit and minerality, with hints of oak spices. Nicely done! | 96 | 2026-2046 | |
| 2021 | Seven Apart | Basalt | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Atlas Peak | Red | Table | $295.00 | The 2021 Basalt Cabernet is larger and broader-shouldered, continuing to grow in richness and complexity. It provides a bold yet elegant experience that stands out distinctly from the rest of the range, showcasing its unique sense of place and identity with pride and strength. Fresh, round, and approachable, this wine is both expressive and flavorful. Its mineral-driven character, paired with succulent acidity, contributes to a beautiful balance, making it a truly remarkable Cabernet. Wow! | 97 | 2026-2050 | |
| 2021 | Seven Apart | Summit | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Atlas Peak | Red | Table | $450.00 | Utterly beautiful, the 2021 Summit took me on a ride like a roller coaster, climbing to the top before rushing down. It has a complex yet sincere kiss of herbal essence with plenty of seductive red fruit notes that fill and excite the palate. Balanced and complex with succulent acidity, this full-bodied Cabernet offers a satisfyingly long finish that lingers like crazy. Wow! I wanted more! | 99 | 2026-2055 | |
| 2022 | Seven Apart | Expedition | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $185.00 | This wine is lush and fruit-forward, with noticeably more extraction and tannins than the previous vintage. While the 2021 vintage shows potential for aging, the 2022 Expedition is rich and rounded, offering an immensely pleasing and approachable expression. It stands out as one of the better reds from the 2022 Napa Valley offerings that I have tasted this year from various producers. Seven Apart clearly knows what they are doing, and I trust them to deliver even in challenging vintages. Well done! | 93+ | 2024-2038 | |
| 2022 | Seven Apart | Shale | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Atlas Peak | Red | Table | $295.00 | The Shale exhibits the same generous character as the 2022 range. It presents a unique sincerity to its sense of place, featuring a fresh and rocky expression while showcasing oak and dusty tannins that frame this full-bodied Cabernet. The mid-palate reveals hints of flint alongside expressive dark fruit, smoothly transitioning to a lush yet firm finish. | 95+ | 2026-2045 | |
| 2022 | Seven Apart | Basalt | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Atlas Peak | Red | Table | $295.00 | Rich and round, the 2022 Basalt is expressive with juicy, red-fruited flavors that reveal a firm structure that gradually softens on the palate. It is full-bodied and fresh, showcasing oak with a sincere expression of Cabernet Sauvignon grown at a higher elevation. A soft herbal essence complements it and notes of black cherry and blackberry nuances. The wine concludes in a lingering spicy finish that will benefit from additional chilling and decanting and will have no challenges aging beautifully. Bravo! | 97 | 2026-2048 | |
| 2022 | Seven Apart | Summit | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Atlas Peak | Red | Table | $450.00 | The wine is big and bold, yet not overwhelming. It makes an immediate impression with its captivating and seductive aroma. The 2022 Summit is full of power and elegance, featuring balanced tannins and a energetic acidity that enhances its full-bodied character. The mid-palate reveals delightful oak spices, leading to a firm finish that lingers and holds into the aftertaste. It’s a highly engaging and cerebral wine that keeps me coming back for more—I can’t put my glass down. | 97 | 2028-2055 | |
| 2023 | Seven Apart | Expedition | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $185.00 | Tasted as a barrel sample, the nose is still very primary, featuring rich and abundant aromas of juicy dark red and black fruits that are both supple and expressive. Medium to full-bodied, the palate reveals still-tight tannins that will undoubtedly round out nicely before it hits the market. I anticipate that this wine will receive acclaim and success upon its release. I look forward to tasting it again from the bottle in another year or so. Well done! | 92-94 | ||
| 2023 | Ampleur | Cabernet Sauvignon Hayne Vineyard | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $150.00 | Tasted as a barrel sample, the Cabernet is fresh, complex, and fruity, with notes of black raspberry and lush dark cherry. It is full-bodied, fleshy, and ripe with a juicy core and exhibits rich and layered characteristics, showcasing its depth beautifully. The wine opens to reveal floral expressions, balanced with the wine’s rich mid-palate, before revealing additional layers and a clean finish. This beauty will have no problem aging to its 15th birthday and beyond. | 92-94 | ||
| 2023 | Rutherford Hill | Sauvignon Blanc AJT Collection | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Rutherford | White | Table | $35.00 | Made with 13% Sauvignon Gris, the 2023 Sauvignon Blanc AJT Collection is fresh and citrus-driven, showcasing bright lemon notes along with hints of key lime pie and a touch of toasty oak. This wine offers a decent balance on both the nose and palate. The mouthfeel is fresh while presenting a variety of layers and textures that glide to a surprisingly smooth finish. As you savor it, notes of citrus blossom and lemon meringue emerge over the aftertaste that delivers well for the price. | 89 | 2025 – 2027 | |
| 2023 | Rutherford Hill | Vermentino AJT Collection | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Rutherford | White | Table | $35.00 | The 2023 Vermentino has a beautiful and complex nose, featuring fresh floral aromas alongside a delightful hint of peaches. It has a medium body with a clean, spicy mid-palate that showcases notes of honeysuckle, leading to a lingering and enjoyable spicy finish. This wine is food-friendly, approachable, and easy to savor due to its pleasant texture. Given its exceptional quality for the price, it is arguably one of the best bottles of Vermentino produced in Napa Valley. This is a smart purchase, and it’s worth buying multiple bottles! | 90 | 2025 – 2028 | |
| 2022 | Rutherford Hill | Chardonnay Napa Valley | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Los Carneros | White | Table | $40.00 | Immediately, fragrant notes of oak and vanilla embrace the nose, accompanied by subtle hints of pineapple, white peach, and mandarin. The mouthfeel is creamy and lush, highlighting ample vanilla and oak that lingers persistently. Over time, it develops a slightly phenolic quality, making it very food-friendly. Medium to full-bodied, the aftertaste reveals notes of creamed corn over the long, spicy, and oaky finish. | 89+ | 2025 – 2031 | |
| 2022 | Rutherford Hill | Merlot Napa Valley | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $38.00 | The 2022 Merlot Napa Valley is soft and succulent, featuring ripe plummy notes and hints of black cherry. This sturdy, value-driven wine has slightly gripping tannins that gradually tighten before expanding into a smooth finish. These food-friendly tannins pair well with salami, cured meats, and any other types of noshy and meaty appetizers. The aftertaste develops slowly, revealing subtle hints of maple syrup that enhance its overall complexity, especially given its attractive price point. | 88 | 2025 – 2029 | |
| 2022 | Rutherford Hill | Merlot Stags Leap District | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Stags Leap District | Red | Table | $75.00 | The 2022 Merlot Stags Leap District is primarily made from Merlot, with remaining portions of 6% Petit Verdot and 4% Cabernet Sauvignon rounding out the wine. It opens with a seductive yet subtle aroma that has an underlying mineral quality. On the palate, it is fleshy and firm, offering a spicy and juicy experience along with a firm, tannic structure. You’ll find layers of olive, black plum, and dusty black cherries complemented by elegant oak notes, culminating in a spicy, lingering finish. This wine is pure and reflects its terroir. Be sure to keep an eye out for any of Rutherford Hill’s sub-appellation-specific “black-label” Merlots. Nicely done! | 92 | 2026 – 2034 | |
| 2022 | Rutherford Hill | Merlot Oak Knoll District | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Oak Knoll District | Red | Table | $75.00 | The nose is instantly captivating and fresh, featuring notes of juicy plum with spicy undertones. The 2022 Merlot from the Oak Knoll District showcases refinement, freshness, and a beautiful balance. It is medium to full-bodied, with tight tannins and a long, complex finish, which give way to elegant hints of pencil shavings and purple flowers that emerge with grace and precision. This is a well-crafted Merlot that you’ll find yourself wanting more of and best of all; it feels like it should cost nearly double, so don’t hesitate to buy it. In a valley dominated by Cabernet Sauvignon, this beautiful Merlot will make a believer out of anyone. | 93+ | 2025 – 2036 | |
| 2022 | Rutherford Hill | Merlot Carneros | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Los Carneros | Red | Table | $75.00 | Opening to a beautifully floral nose, the 2022 Merlot from Carneros features scents of juicy plum that overflows from the glass. The aroma is abundant with purple flowers, while the palate remains tight, showcasing its longevity and freshness. Surprisingly complex, this brilliant example of Merlot proves that Merlot can absolutely age gracefully. The finish is long and intricate, with a food-friendly hint of spice and soft leafiness that harmonizes beautifully over time. I am going back for more. Nicely done! | 93 | 2026 – 2035 | |
| 2022 | Rutherford Hill | Winemaker’s Blend | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $88.00 | Made from a blend of 73% Merlot and 27% Cabernet Sauvignon, the 2022 Winemaker’s Blend is refined and elegant with fresh plums, black cherry, and hints of oak, this full-bodied blend offers pitch-perfect juiciness and mineral tension. Smooth with spicy and succulent tannins, it’s very food-friendly and will remain so for years to come. Originally a completely different blend, it now resembles a Right Bank Bordeaux blend made with a Cabernet clone from Bordeaux. Amazingly complex and fresh. Buy the case—the price is sure to go up! | 93+ | 2025 – 2035 | |
| 2022 | Rutherford Hill | Heaven’s Peak Red Blend | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $90.00 | The 2022 Heaven’s Peak Red Blend is an attractive blend of 58% Cabernet Sauvignon and 42% Merlot. It presents bold, juicy, and spicy aromas, enhanced by lush purple floral notes and plummy essences. The nose introduces a brilliant balance of dusty minerality alongside baked earth elements. On the palate, vibrant red and black fruit flavors, including dusty plum skin and crushed black cherries, race across the mid-palate. The mouthfeel is elegant and balanced, showcasing layers of juicy fruit, refined florals, and fleshy plums. This wine is very food-friendly and concludes with a long, spicy finish. It’s a well-made red blend that is very food-friendly. Nicely done! Yum, I’m not spitting this one out! | 94+ | 2027 – 2037 | |
| 2022 | Rutherford Hill | Cabernet Sauvignon AJT Collection | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Rutherford | Red | Table | $65.00 | The 2022 Cabernet Sauvignon AJT Collection is predominantly Cabernet Sauvignon, complemented by 3% Cabernet Franc, 2% Petit Verdot, and 2% Merlot. This wine is rich, round, and juicy, offering a long, complex mouthfeel that avoids being overdone. It offers plenty of pleasure with just-ripe and accessible fruit with a delicate touch, showcasing mineral tension and beautiful balance. Fresh and complete, it delivers a sincere, lingering finish. For anyone who believes that all Napa Cabernets are merely juicy, boozy, and oaky, this wine will change their mind. The true strength of this Cabernet exists in its elegance and purity. Bravo! | 93 | 2025 – 2034 | |
| 2022 | Rutherford Hill | Heaven’s Peak Cabernet Sauvignon | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Rutherford | Red | Table | $125.00 | The 2022 Heaven’s Peak Cabernet Sauvignon, made with splashes of Petit Verdot and Malbec, is rich, round, juicy, and bold, showcasing ripe fruit and oak aromas in the glass. It has an impressive presence, featuring polished and shiny oak notes that complement its generous style, making it a delight for any Napa Cabernet lover. Expect flavors of crème de cassis and Chambord, accompanied by spicy oak undertones. On the palate, it is elegantly oaked, culminating in a toasty finish with nutty and baking spice notes. There is ample oak for those who appreciate it. Overall, this wine is well-crafted and will deliver pleasure to those who enjoy a more generous and voluptuous Napa Cabernet. | 94 | 2025 – 2036 | |
| 2022 | Vicarious by Modus Operandi Cellars | Vicarious Red Blend | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $55.00 | Made from a blend of 50% Syrah, 30% Merlot, and 20% Malbec, the 2022 Vicarious Red Blend is very fresh and juicy, showcasing a mineral-driven nose with a dark fruited core. Full-bodied and with energetic acidity, the palate reveals tight tannins alongside notes of bitter black tea, blackberry skin, and red floral elements of potpourri. It concludes with a long, lip-smacking finish, and it has me coming back for more. | 92 | 2026-2033 | |
| 2022 | Vicarious by Modus Operandi Cellars | Vicarious Cabernet Sauvignon | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $65.00 | The 2022 Vicarious Cabernet Sauvignon displays a big and juicy profile with plenty of oak influences. The tannins are tight and gripping, making it very food-friendly. The wine is fresh and has a generous frame. It offers a long finish that is clearly punching above its weight class and over-delivers for the price. | 91 | 2025-2033 | |
| 2022 | Modus Operandi Cellars | Aetherius Pinot Noir | USA, California, North Coast, Sonoma County, Sonoma Coast | Red | Table | $135.00 | The 2022 Aetherius Pinot Noir is instantly impressive, showcasing layered and bright red cherry notes, along with succulent acidity and freshness. The wine exhibits precision and ripeness, featuring just-ripe and crunchy red fruit expressions, complemented by bright acidity. It is very expressive and pure, with the wine’s structure lifting the palate, resulting in a pleasurable and precise drinking experience that ends with an elegant and clean finish. | 93+ | 2025-2037 | |
| 2023 | Modus Operandi Cellars | Aetherius Pinot Noir | USA, California, North Coast, Sonoma County, Sonoma Coast | Red | Table | $135.00 | The 2023 Aetherius Pinot Noir is broad-shouldered and generous, with an attractive array of aromas that waft from the glass, with delicate red spice essences. The nose is layered and bold, with notes of red tea and potpourri essence. On the palate, the wine ends with a tight tannic structure that will benefit from another year or two in the bottle. | 93 | 2026-2035 | |
| 2021 | Modus Operandi Cellars | Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $150.00 | The 2021 Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon is still tight, while displaying a fresh and vibrant nose. Incredibly complex, this full-bodied wine has focus and power, with plenty of attractive oak spices to round out its expression. On the palate, it reveals a robust mineral tension and freshness that will deliver pleasure for more than a decade. Nicely done! | 94+ | 2026-2038 | |
| 2022 | Modus Operandi Cellars | Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $150.00 | The 2022 Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon presents a fresh and complex nose, showcasing dark red fruit essences with precision and power, along with a delightful floral aspect. On the palate, the wine is juicy and fresh, featuring lively tannins that grip and hold throughout. It has a brilliantly balanced structure that will allow the wine to slowly uncoil over time, revealing its character as a true powerhouse Cabernet. Ending with a long, lingering, and complex finish, the wine is hedonistic and fresh, framed generously, demonstrating its style with everything in balance. I’m going to finish my glass. | 95 | 2026-2037 | |
| 2022 | Modus Operandi Cellars | Houyi Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $225.00 | Generous, juicy, and fresh, the 2022 Houyi Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon showcases a core of oak spices, revealing a touch of volatility on the nose. The wine is fresh and complex, with a rocky core, while the oak remains shiny and expressive. The Cabernet displays fresh notes of popcorn kernel and a tannic edge, making it very food-friendly. Overall, the wine exudes elegance and power. | 96 | 2026-2044 | |
| 2022 | Modus Operandi Cellars | Sage Ridge Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $195.00 | The 2022 Sage Ridge Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon presents a generous and firm frame that overflows with complex dark red fruit wafting from the nose. The wine’s structure is big, beautiful, and still slightly compact in its youth. With succulent acidity, the wine reveals incredible complexity with a rich and rounded mouthfeel. Possessing remarkable depth, complexity, and freshness, with a larger volume of expression yet a tighter compact structure, this beauty ends with a vibrant and long-lasting finish. Bravo! | 96 | 2026-2045 | |
| 2022 | Modus Operandi Cellars | Rocca-Collinetta Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Coombsville | Red | Table | $185.00 | The 2022 Rocca-Collinetta Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon is incredibly complex and fresh, with a generous frame that oozes with layers of bitter dark chocolate, black tea, and black berry compote. Full-bodied and still showing firm tannins, complemented by notes of resinous purple flowers, this deep and dark expression of Cabernet is a powerful wine that will stand up to just about anything that you throw at it from the grill. It has a firm, broad structure with a dense and chewy finish that leaves me craving a bone-in ribeye. If this wine were a movie, it would be the movie 300. “This is Sparta!” | 98+ | 2027-2050 | |
| 2022 | Modus Operandi Cellars | Antithesis | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $185.00 | The 2022 Antithesis is a super fun blend that showcases refined elegance. The nose reveals complex aromas that are both aromatic and inviting, with Merlot rounding out the expression, while Petite Sirah fills in the edges. On the palate, the wine is rich and layered, offering a soft phenolic grip, and demonstrates how complex and utterly cerebral a wine it is and has me coming back for more. What a remarkably focused and impressive red blend. Bravo! | 96+ | 2027-2046 | |
| 2022 | Modus Operandi Cellars | Collection Cabernet Sauvignon | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $325.00 | Instantly impressive with luxurious and elegant oak tones that sway out of the glass, the 2022 Collection Cabernet Sauvignon is impressively fresh. Overflowing with precision and finesse, this wine aged in Collection barrels, made from oak trees that were specially selected for harvesting. Jason Moore of Modus Operandi Cellars honors the trees by listing the name and age of each tree on the label. This profoundly gorgeous wine is impressively rich, round, and focused, in a full-bodied frame with the oak driving the myriads of complexities that await the drinker at every turn. It beautifully highlights the wood and the tree that produced the barrel, making it a serious collector’s item that will age for decades. Made in excruciatingly low quantities, this bottle will complete any serious wine collector’s cellar. Bravo, Jason! Take a victory lap, you deserve it! | 99 | 2027–2055 | |
| 2023 | Morlet Family Vineyards | Ma Douce | USA, California, North Coast, Sonoma County, Fort Ross-Seaview | White | Table | $145.00 | The 2023 Ma Douce showcases a beautiful Chardonnay that is unfiltered and unfined, offering an open and approachable expression. Fresh and juicy, the nose features ripe citrus and delicate oak nuances that enhance its freshness without overwhelming it. With hints of lemon pastry cream and oatmeal complemented by vanilla, alongside succulent sweet Meyer lemon and notes of sautéed almonds, the wine is impeccably balanced. It is full-bodied with a surprising weight and ripe, lively acidity compounded by layers of complexity. Very food-friendly, it delivers a lingering spicy finish. | 94 | 2025-2040 | |
| 2023 | Morlet Family Vineyards | Ma Princesse | USA, California, North Coast, Sonoma County, Russian River Valley | White | Table | $155.00 | Presenting with a slightly hazy core from being unfiltered and unfined, the 2023 Ma Princesse reveals a core of citrus, demonstrating less oak influence while making up for it with pronounced mineral tension. It has the same generosity as Ma Douce, but with more pronounced mineral notes. The wine has a slow rolling action that will develop beautifully over time; just be patient. Your patience will be rewarded. | 94+ | 2025-2040 | |
| 2023 | Morlet Family Vineyards | Coup de Cœur | USA, California, North Coast, Sonoma County, Sonoma Coast | White | Table | $235.00 | Rich and round with a seductive, heady richness, the 2023 Coup de Cœur Chardonnay is impeccable as it impresses with a powerful elegance. Oak spices and sweet citrus notes contribute to its gravitas and strength. Layered with spices, it features notes of brioche, almonds, and vanilla, complemented by hints of cardamom and cinnamon. The wine is full-bodied and fresh, providing a surprising mineral tension along with flavors of yellow apples and notes of lemon pastry cream. It finishes with a hedonistically spicy, lingering sensation that develops on the aftertaste from the slightly boozy and generously framed Chardonnay. The wine is fresh and is sure to age beautifully, gaining in complexity over time. | 96+ | 2026-2042 | |
| 2023 | Morlet Family Vineyards | Côteaux Nobles | USA, California, North Coast, Sonoma County, Fort Ross-Seaview | Red | Table | $160.00 | The 2023 Côteaux Nobles showcases a nose of classic red cherries, complemented by notes of red and black tea, wild raspberries, and spices. Baking spices, clove, and wild bay leaf reveal themselves on the palate, alongside nuances of vanilla and ripe cherry. This medium to full-bodied wine features tannins that slowly take hold and persist through the finish, highlighting red fruit and freshness, with high-toned red spices that make this beauty very food-friendly. | 94 | 2025-2040 | |
| 2023 | Morlet Family Vineyards | En Famille | USA, California, North Coast, Sonoma County, Fort Ross-Seaview | Red | Table | $170.00 | The 2023 En Famille has a nose that is slightly shy, not showcasing as many red fruit tones typically associated with Pinot Noir; however, the wine is more textural and complex. It is medium to full-bodied, displaying impeccable weight and grip with a phenolic spice and tightening tannic structure that runs through the mid-palate. The wine concludes with a spicy, lingering finish, revealing hints of roasted red tea and forest heartwood. This is a wine that requires time to fully reveal itself. | 95 | 2025-2038 | |
| 2023 | Morlet Family Vineyards | Joli Cœur | USA, California, North Coast, Sonoma County, Fort Ross-Seaview | Red | Table | $190.00 | High-toned red fruits and notes of graphite seduce the nose of the 2023 Joli Cœur Pinot Noir with the seriousness of a world-class wine. The mouthfeel is very fresh and elegant, with silky tannins that glide across the mid-palate, while the fruit condition and concentration remain ripe and pristine. It has clearly defined Pinot Noir characteristics, showcasing a youthful, very ripe profile and firm texture, revealing beautifully integrated oak influences that lift the overall expression. This beauty ends with a lingering spicy finish that has me coming back for more! | 96 | 2026-2038 | |
| 2022 | Morlet Family Vineyards | Bouquet Garni | USA, California, North Coast, Sonoma County, Bennett Valley | Red | Table | $155.00 | The 2022 Bouquet Garni Syrah exhibits dark-fruited aromas of spicy blackberry and spiced plums. It has a spicy core and is notably fresher on the palate, showing hints of dry-aged steak rather than hung sausages. The Syrah gradually reveals delicate floral notes and offers hints of lavender, along with a delightful spicy note of white peppercorn. It has an enjoyable tannic grip that persists through the softer, more mineral-driven finish, making it a great match for food, especially lamb and wild game. Decanting is recommended. | 93 | 2025-2035 | |
| 2023 | Morlet Family Vineyards | Les Petits Morlet | USA, California, North Coast, Sonoma County | White | Table | $85.00 | The 2023 Les Petits Morlet presents a clean and fresh profile with notes of sweet lemons and hints of tropical flowers, white melon, and yellow apples. Softly oaky, the wine showcases a beautiful citrus blossom. It offers nuances of oak and vanilla spices that elevate the experience, along with hints of lees and a delightful texture that captivates the mid-palate. Fresh and slightly waxy, the wine concludes with an approachable and accessible sweet citrus-laced finish. | 92 | 2025-2035 | |
| 2023 | Morlet Family Vineyards | La Proportion Dorée | USA, California, North Coast, Sonoma County | White | Table | $160.00 | The 2023 La Proportion Dorée, made from 63% Sémillon, 36% Sauvignon Blanc, and 1% Muscadelle, features citrus aromas alongside notes of yellow apple and yellow cherry. Offering some lees and mineral tension with hints of oak, the wine is medium to full-bodied on the palate. Electric mineral tension showcases phenolic grip, driving the incredibly pleasurable finish that encourages food pairings, particularly with cheeses. | 94 | 2025-2040 | |
| 2022 | Morlet Family Vineyards | Les Petits Morlet | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley | Red | Table | $135.00 | The 2022 Les Petits Morlet offers fresh and ripe notes of dusty black plums and blackberries, along with hints of graphite and pencil lead. With a medium to full body, the wine delivers a soft mineral tension, complemented by black tea tannins that culminate in a lingering spicy finish. A touch of herbal notes enhances the Cabernet Sauvignon, making the wine both fresh and delightfully spicy. Nicely done. | 92 | 2025-2035 | |
| 2022 | Morlet Family Vineyards | Mon Chevalier | USA, California, North Coast, Sonoma County, Knights Valley | Red | Table | $300.00 | The nose gradually reveals dark red and dusty fruit notes with hints of mocha and black cherry, complemented by an earthy and mineral-driven core. Medium to full-bodied, the 2022 Mon Chevalier Cabernet Sauvignon shines beautifully, offering a pure and expressive palate with fresh notes of sage. The wine bursts with impeccable precision and mineral tension, showcasing its intricacies, layered with complexity. It has a quiet strength and prestige that becomes more noticeable the longer you allow it to interact with your senses. If you are patient and let the wine come to you, you’ll appreciate how truly remarkable it is. Bravo! | 95+ | 2025-2040 | |
| 2022 | Morlet Family Vineyards | Cœur de Vallée | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Oakville | Red | Table | $400.00 | The 2022 Cœur de Vallée displays elegantly beautiful power, featuring notes of oak and a dusty core of dark red and black fruit. Medium to full-bodied, the palate grips with fine-grained tannins, and the wine is brilliantly oaked, matching the frame of fruit and offering layered complexity. The purity and freshness are refined, expressive, and pure, with the tannic edge in brilliant harmony with its structure, delivering an absolutely long, elegant, and pure finish. It’s gorgeous! Bravo! | 97 | 2026-2050 | |
| 2022 | Morlet Family Vineyards | Morlet Estate | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, St. Helena | Red | Table | $400.00 | Instantly impressive and showcasing an unmistakable Napa Cabernet profile, the 2022 Morlet Estate Cabernet Sauvignon features a tight, expressive structure with juicy red and black fruits intertwined with elegant oak nuances. Full-bodied and balanced by pronounced floral notes that enhance its character, this wine has a firm mineral tension that heightens the overall enjoyment. Elegant, fine-grained tannins provide a pure, graceful finish, demonstrating an impressive harmony of power, precision, and grace. It concludes with a delightfully tannic finish and a lingering spicy note that invites another sip. | 96+ | 2027-2045 | |
| 2022 | Morlet Family Vineyards | Passionnément | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Oakville | Red | Table | $425.00 | The 2022 Passionnément has a bright core of dark red and black fruit tones that overflow from the glass, offering potpourri expressions with defined, elegant oak nuances. Very perfumed, it showcases fresh aromas of oak spices and bright coffee, demonstrating precision, grace, and focus. The sum of the parts is ultimately greater than the individual sites, with florals, freshness, and purity. Ending with elegance, focus, and grace, this wine is ideal for fine cuts of meat like filet mignon. Its elegance is devastatingly gorgeous! | 98 | 2028-2055 | |
| 2022 | Morlet Family Vineyards | Force Tranquille | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Oakville | Red | Table | $425.00 | A delightful expression showcasing elegance and grace, the 2022 Force Tranquille reveals notes of black cherry and sweet, juicy red herbs that sway with freshness. The wine presents a seductive frame, enticing with dusty fruit paired with ripe cherry notes, graphite, and sweet oak spices. Herbal notes lean towards sweet red pepper rather than green bell pepper, resulting in a delightful and expressive profile. Very impressive in its petite frame, this wine will impress even the most skeptical Cabernet Franc lovers. | 97 | 2026-2038 | |
| 2022 | Morlet Family Vineyards | Force de la Nature | USA, California, North Coast, Napa Valley, Oakville | Red | Table | $500.00 | Bold and vibrant, this stunning wine is intricately layered and firmly structured at its core, showcasing expressive black cherry and spiced blackberry notes. The 2022 Force de la Nature Cabernet Franc offers a complex profile with layers of juicy, ripe fruit, complemented by elegant oak spices that enhance the overall experience and contribute to its impressive and refined character. This wine is broad-shouldered and effortlessly displays a beautiful sense of focus and freshness throughout. It is truly one of the best and most devastatingly gorgeous Cabernet Francs in all of Napa Valley! | 98 | 2026-2045 |
Copyright Notice:
All wine reviews, scores, and related content within the AnthonyMueller.com Wine Review Database are protected under copyright law and are the exclusive intellectual property of Anthony Mueller Consulting LLC. While this information is free to read and access, any reproduction, distribution, or republication of the content without prior written consent is strictly prohibited. Unauthorized use constitutes copyright infringement and may result in legal action. Contact us if you have any questions.